JFK ASSASSINATION ARGUMENTS
(PART 453)


"CURT JESTER" SAID:

I do believe the person Mrs. Reid saw had a full bottle of Coke...


DAVID VON PEIN SAID:

Yep. Oswald did have a Coke in his hands when Reid saw him on 11/22/63.


"CURT" SAID:

...and that the boys had a habit of coming up there and asking for change for the machine.


DVP SAID:

Which Oswald did not do at around 12:30 PM on November 22nd.


"CURT" SAID:

You would think they wouldn't climb all those stairs as a habit for a coke on the first floor, or in the case of Oswald if he had one on the first floor, why he would want to come up to the second floor with it?


DVP SAID:

He didn't climb any stairs to buy his Coke, idiot. He DESCENDED four flights--from the 6th Floor to the 2nd Floor--and then bought it after his encounter with Baker and Truly.

Anyway, you seem to be reiterating part of my point from my earlier post -- i.e., if Oswald's favorite soft drink (Dr. Pepper) was available on the first floor (which it definitely was), and he was already on the first floor (which he claimed he was when the shooting occurred)....then why go UP one floor to get a drink?

Oswald lied. Simple as that.


"CURT" SAID:

Anyway, look down about 3/4's of the way down on the link [referring to CE741]. Looks like a soda machine to me on the second floor.


DVP SAID:

CE741 isn't showing a soda machine. It's showing a candy machine.

Here's the 2nd-Floor lunchroom Coke machine (with the candy machine also visible).


"CURT" SAID:

Also looks like Oswald's shirt looks more like the guy in the doorway than Lovelady's shirt, don't it?


DVP SAID:

Who cares? Since it was positively Lovelady in the doorway in the Altgens picture, then your comment above is a moot one, isn't it?

Or would you like to resurrect the "Oswald Was In The Doorway After All" nonsense yet again, Mr. Conspiracy?

David Von Pein
March 11, 2009